FOOKAY

Top 10 Movies

of

2024

It's hard to pin down what 2024 was like for movies. On one end of the spectrum, you were spoilt for choice pretty much regardless of which genre you prefer. On the other end of the spectrum, the bad movies were really bad and we had more of those than we deserved. For now, we're going to focus on the great ones.

10

Strange Darling

dir. JT Mollner

Like Red Letter Media, I’m catching everything I can with Kyle Gallner in it. This was a standout for me. Not only was his performance electrifying, but Willa Fitzgerald kept me guessing the entire time–it's hard to believe the studio wanted her replaced. A one-night stand turns into a murder spree and its time jumps will keep you in suspense the entire time. There’s some truly tense moments that I wish more movies would take notes from. Not only that, the entire vibe of the movie is immaculate. It feels otherworldly and heightened and yet grounded enough to not make you second guess what's happening.

A woman hiding in a forest from the movie Strange Darling

9

Caddo Lake

dir. Logan George & Celine Held

It gives itself away too soon, but maybe that was the point. The journey to the answer can be just as riveting and that’s certainly the case here. I can’t say much without giving it all away, but what struck me was how there’s different family dynamics at play here that ultimately end up playing all the same notes. An 8-year old girl goes missing on a lake and you learn so much about the characters in how they react to this event. And it’s key to see how they react because it makes the denouement all the more satisfying. The more you pay attention, the better the payoff.

A woman holding a rope from the movie Caddo Lake

8

Gladiator II

dir. Ridley Scott

This one is difficult to explain. The first movie has so many things working in its favor; chief among them is when it came out. Gladitor’s release was at a time when large-scale epics still had a lot of runway. Gladiator II, being released nearly a decade and a half later, must now work against absolutely titanic shifts in movie preferences and consumption. And that’s probably why I love it: despite those changes, it’s not a small movie faked into being big or a movie hamstrung by budget, it’s an actual BIG movie with all of its budget on screen. The sets are incredible, the costumes are seemingly unique to everyone on screen, and there’s Denzel Washington working to turn every scene to 11. I don’t think this will have the lasting power of the first, but I am exceedingly happy we got it - shame it had to be a sequel that undoes some of the things that made the Gladiator so special.

A man tackling another man from the movie Gladiator 2

7

Civil War

dir. Alex Garland

We all had an idea of what this movie was going to be when the trailers hit. Alex Garland though wasn’t interested in telling us the obvious story though. We never learn what the “sides” are, why they’re fighting, or even when the fighting started. Instead, through a journalistic lens, we follow four individuals on their road trip to interview the President before he’s overthrown. Perhaps not perfectly, but purposefully and poignantly, we’re shown the necessity of impartial journalism. When we’re now fed the “other type of American” narrative during what is now our 24 hour news feed, that Jesse Plemmons scene doesn’t seem so far off.

What I found this movie did so well though that perhaps isn’t talked about enough is showing what it would like if the type of war footage from other countries we see so often in our news... was here. Garland seemed to be sick of hearing people say “I can’t imagine that happening here,” when he was picking hit shots.

Oh, and the final action scene is Black Hawk Down levels of intense.

A man holding a rifle from the movie Civil War

6

Longlegs

dir. Osgood Perkins

Nicolas Cage as a serial killer is all most of us really needed to hear. The marketing did a lot of heavy lifting for this one, but I still managed to be enthralled. It’s a slow burn, but if you’re a fan of movies that dip into occult mysteries, this is an easy recommend. I’ve gone back to this one a couple of times just because it feels like there’s always something on the edges of the screen. The sense of dread just from that is worth the time investment. Luckily, we also get a standout performance from Cage that will leave you squirming. Maika Monroe’s portrayal of obsession to the point of self-sacrifice also deserves accolades. The ending doesn’t quite connect for me in the way that I was hoping while watching it, but that’s a lot of movies these days. Watch it with all the lights off and the sound way up.

A person screaming in a car from the movie Longlegs

5

The Order

dir. Justin Kurzel

This one didn’t get a lot of traction (at least from what I saw) and that’s a damn shame. We don’t get thrillers like this very often anymore and we certainly don’t get ones that are this good. The Order tells the story of a white supremacist group in the Pacific Northwest and their rise to prominence. Jude Law (in a truly standout role here, just wow) is an FBI agent that partners with a local deputy (Tye Sheridan also turning in solid work) and while they know exactly what’s going on, they consistently find themselves one step behind. It doesn’t just focus on the procedurals of the case either, but also casts a light on the group itself and how they were able to recruit so many people (while also making sure to not be at all favorable to that viewpoint). It’s a tightrope for sure and director Justin Kurzel manages to walk it. This one will sit with you for a while.

A man holding a shotgun from the movie The Order

4

Alien Romulus

dir. Fede Alvarez

I actually am part of the group that has liked the recent Alien movies, but I will happily admit that’s largely down to liking the visual style so much and not getting too wrapped up in how they connect to the previous movies. Alien Romulus though manages to do both: have that vintage tech feel of the first movies and marrying that with Alien (1979)’s horror roots. It must be said: I could have spent the entire movie on that colony from the first act; what a wonderfully realized setting. Luckily, we get a bit spoiled with some creative horror moments and some of the best CGI of the year. And not only do we get the nail-biting xenomorph danger, there’s also the ticking clock of the spaceship they’re on heading straight into a planet’s rings.

I thoroughly enjoyed this movie and it probably would have landed higher if we didn’t have the ridiculous callbacks; when I had forgotten about the Ian Holm resurrection, I’m beat over the head with the “get away from her” line. Just ripped me straight out of the movie with those bits. It's a testament to how much I enjoyed the movie though that I still ranked it this high despite that shortcoming.

A star over a planet from the movie Alien Romulus

3

The Bikeriders

dir. Jeff Nichols

Why is this so high? If you know anything about me and my love for motorcycles, this is probably not at all a surprise. But really, this is the best evidence I’ve ever seen for what makes motorcycles so special. If you read the synopsis of “a motorcycle club transforms into a violent gang”, you’re going to go in with the wrong idea. The movie is more a series of vignettes about why misfits and “others” find themselves on two wheels and why they’re drawn to form a motorcycle club. Of course the bikes are beautiful (and sound incredible, especially in theater), of course Austin Butler and Tom Hardy look the absolute business, and of course everything is perfectly tinged for that vintage feel. What makes it all come together though is Jeff Nichols’s unique capture of his characters. No matter who it is, we’re never given a sympathetic or dismissive view, only an honest one which makes the characters feel all the more real.

Why this was so important to me boils down to the last scene of the movie where Butler’s Benny character hears a motorcycle off in the distance and catches himself daydreaming of better times. If you know, you know.

A man sitting on a bike from the movie The Bikeriders

2

Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga

dir. George Miller

Let’s get this out of the way: this was never going to be on the same level as Mad Max: Fury Road. That’s a top 5 movie for me. I don’t even buy the narrative of “I liked Fury Road better, even though I know Furiosa is the better movie”. BUT! This movie still blew past my expectations. They could have taken the easy way out (the easy way being what so many sequels are doing nowadays: just doing a copy/paste of the first movie), but they didn’t and that deserves recognition. We didn’t get another chase movie; we got an origin story that actually makes Fury Road even better upon rewatch. That’s frankly impressive on so many levels. The leads, Taylor-Joy and Hemsworth, are two opposite ends of the apocalyptic stick and it makes for some really gripping scenes.

For me though, what I just couldn’t believe was seeing how Miller still has it in him to just drop in absolutely top tier action scenes. I was worried we wouldn’t get the same level of “whoa” moments like we did with Fury Road, but that worry was absolutely squashed with that monster truck scene. An all-timer for sure.

Oh and don’t get me started with how many awesome motorcycles were on display here. I’d do terrible things to get The Thunderbike in my garage.

A fleet of vehicles on a desolate landscape from the movie Furiosa

1

Dune: Part Two

dir. Denis Villeneuve

This isn’t the movie that stayed with me the most. It’s not even the one I connected with the most. It was absolutely the one I was most immersed in though. It didn’t take more than a few moments for me to lose myself in winds of Arrakis. There’s no denying: this is what happens when every aspect of a movie is delivering at the highest level. The sound design is otherworldly, the music is another Zimmer suite of bangers, and the effects make you realize how bad we’ve had it these past few years. There’s much to say about Paul Atreides’ falsely earned rise to power and how it will unfortunately impact his followers, but I’d almost rather wait for Part 3 to really sink my teeth into that aspect of the story. On that journey to becoming a prophet, we’re shown numerous times how Paul is pulled and pushed in ways that make his downfall understandable, but not forgivable. Much like events in the real world, the right thing seems obvious and even achievable, but the impact of every decision made often leads to less than desirable outcomes.

Watch this one as loud as you can stand. This movie delivers more when you let yourself get lost in it.

Sandworms from the movie Dune Part Two

Honorable Mentions

A poster for the movie Kill

Kill

An action movie that turns into a slasher - what’s not to love? Uses its setting to great effect (trains are always cool and fight scenes on trains are doubly cool) and you’re almost never bored. In a pretty solid year for action movies, this was a standout.

A poster for the movie Smile 2

Smile 2

Unapologetically love the first movie since I felt it was actually scary. The second one turned out to be a solid addition by making its focal point a pop singer. You completely buy her descent into madness and this is one of the few movies that does the “is this scene actually happening or a dream” trope better than most.

A poster for the movie Rebel Ridge

Rebel Ridge

This one gets you from the first scene. It’s tense as hell and you are immediately sucked into Terry’s (played with a fierce intensity by Aaron Pierre) plight and want to know his next move. For some it moved a bit too slow, but I found that it made the action scenes that much more satisfying. The realization that they picked on the wrong guy is one of my favorite scenes of the year.

A poster for the movie Boy Kills World

Boy Kills World

This is a hard one to wrap my head around. I think what made it stick out for me is that it felt like a fighting game story come to life. There’s definitely a heavy video game influence here and for some people that might not work. But if you wanted to know what it would be like to pick a Tekken fighter and then watch a 2 hour movie on that character…

A poster for the movie Oddity

Oddity

Another movie that stood out for one particular scene. To be clear: the whole movie is great and has some of the best scares of the year. But, the home invasion scene in the first act that sets the stage is worth the price of admission alone. More attention should be paid to how such a simple scene can be so damned creepy.

A poster for the movie Its Whats Inside

It’s What’s Inside

You have to stay glued to this just based on the premise of the movie (a group of friends play a game where they get to switch bodies and guess who is who), but it’s worth it. Not only that, it’s a highly stylistic movie and I really got a kick out of some of the transitions and framing happening here. This was a wonderful surprise.

A poster for the movie The Substance

The Substance

I really struggled with whether or not this should be in the top 10. It probably would be if you asked me on another day. No doubt about it though: this movie will stick with you. There are so many aspects of this film that work, but the body horror is the standout (and is getting the most talk time). It’s truly something else and gives Cronenberg a run for his money.

Special Mention

Foe

This movie was not well-reviewed. In looking at what the critics said, the acting was seen as top-notch (Ronan and Mescal, so of course), but it was let down by some iffy sci-fi story components and a so-so script. I’m not here to argue for or against any aspect of the film because I’m still not sure why it connected with me so much. Perhaps it’s the midwest setting or the Black Mirror-esque story or the frequent slow moments where we just get to sit with the characters. I can’t explain why the ending hit me the way it did because it’s certainly been done better elsewhere. This is an enigma to me. I should not have liked this movie (the reviews aren’t wrong after all), but I did and because of that, I felt the need to include it here.

A man sitting on a truck from the movie Foe

That’s it for movies this year. I still have quite a watchlist backlog including Conclave, The Wild Robot, My Old Ass, Nosferatu, Juror #2, A Real Pain and more I’m sure.